Skip to main content
New charcoal architectural shingles on a Connecticut home after a winter roof replacement by Pattison Construction, snow on the ground below

Homeowner guide

Storm Damage Roof Insurance Claim: The Plain-Words Process

The order things need to happen in. This is not legal or insurance advice.

A nor'easter peeled shingles off, a limb came through, hail bruised the south slope. This is the sequence that keeps a bad week from becoming a bad year. We're a licensed roofing contractor and not a public adjuster, so this covers the construction side only. Your policy and your carrier decide the coverage questions.

First: make it safe and stop the water

Stay off the roof. If water is coming in, move what you can and put a bucket under it. Call a contractor to tarp or dry in the damage; we do storm and emergency roof response, and an open roof gets worse by the hour. Keep every receipt from this step.

Document everything before anything is cleaned up

  • Photos from the ground of every side of the house, plus close-ups of anything on the lawn: shingles, flashing, branches.
  • Photos and video of interior damage: ceilings, walls, attic.
  • The date and time of the storm.
  • Don't throw debris away until your carrier has seen the photos.

Call your insurance company, and read your policy

Report the damage promptly; policies set their own reporting windows. Your carrier assigns an adjuster to inspect. Coverage, deductibles, and whether a roof is paid at replacement cost or a depreciated value are set by your policy. We don't interpret policies, and you shouldn't take any roofer's word for what yours covers.

Get a roofer's inspection and written estimate

This is where we come in. We inspect the roof, document the damage from the roof itself, and give you a written estimate for the repair or replacement. We work with homeowners on their insurance claims; if you want us there when the adjuster walks the roof, ask. In June 2025 we replaced a Wallingford roof along with hail-damage repair.

Do I need to replace my roof after hail?

Not always. Hail knocks granules loose and cracks the shingle mat, and the damage can be invisible from the ground. Sometimes it's one slope; sometimes it's the whole roof. An inspection from the roof tells you which, and we'll give you both numbers if both are reasonable.

What we do and don't do

We do the inspection, the dry-in, the written estimate, the permit, the repair or replacement, and the construction-side paperwork. We don't give legal or insurance advice, act as a public adjuster, or promise what your carrier will pay. On the job itself, a storm roof is built like any other roof we do: the crew shows up when we say it will, moves quickly, explains what it's doing, charges a fair price, and leaves the yard clean.

Written by the crew at Pattison Construction, a family-owned general contractor in Wallingford, CT since 1991. GAF Certified Contractor, licensed Connecticut Home Improvement Contractor HIC.0672217. Free estimates, no pressure.

Quick answers

Is roof replacement covered by insurance?

Generally, sudden storm damage is what homeowners policies are written for, and wear, age, and neglect are not. Your policy and your adjuster make that call. Our part is documenting the damage and doing the work.

Should I file a claim for a small repair?

That's between you and your carrier. What we can do is give you a straight repair estimate first, so you know what the fix costs before you decide.

Does the insurance company pick the roofer?

Your carrier pays the claim; you choose who does the work. Ask us for references in your town.

Want a straight answer about your roof?

Free estimates. Honest answers. No pressure. We’re in Wallingford, right down the road.

CallFree Estimate